Ethics in Brief: Competence Requires Consciousness and Avoidance of Bias, Both Implicit and Explicit
By Deborah Wolfe
The very first Rule of the California Rules of Professional Conduct (“CRPC”), 1.1 states:
“(a) A lawyer shall not intentionally, recklessly, with gross negligence, or repeatedly fail to perform legal services with competence.
(b) For purposes of this rule, ‘competence’ in any legal service shall mean to apply the (i) learning and skill, and (ii) mental, emotional, and physical ability reasonably* necessary for the performance of such service.”
…
Competence necessarily includes lawyers maintaining proficiency and keeping current with the law that relates to their practice. It also includes maintaining compliance with the Mandatory Continuing Legal Education requirements, which include at least two credit hours addressing the recognition and elimination of impermissible bias in the courtroom, law offices, attorney-client relationships and attorney-attorney relationships, and many other situations. At least one hour of the Elimination of Bias requirement must focus on implicit bias and bias-reducing strategies regarding race, ethnicity, gender identity, sexual orientation, socioeconomic status, or other characteristics.
The current CRPC also prohibits lawyers from engaging in or knowingly permitting unlawful discrimination relating to a law firm’s operation, as set forth in the very comprehensive Rule 8.4.1, entitled “Prohibited Discrimination, Harassment and Retaliation”. The language in the rule is comprehensive enough to include lawyers’ conduct whether acting within the boundaries of one’s practice or not. It defines “protected characteristics” as including but not limited to “race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, age, military and veteran status, or other category of discrimination prohibited by applicable law, whether the category is actual or perceived.”
Keeping up with the law in order to maintain one’s license is a fairly daunting task. With the amount of legislation passed in California every year, a lawyer can easily miss rulings of the California Courts of Appeals and the Supreme Court when the rulings relate to an area of the law in which the lawyer does not practice.
For example, there have been a number of recent decisions related to Penal Code section 745, called the California Racial Justice Act of 2020 (“RJA”), of which civil lawyers may not be aware. Yet in several rulings related to the RJA in the last two yearsi, the Courts have made it clear that the provisions of PC 745 as it relates to avoiding language, conduct, or any inference of prohibited bias, particularly in making arguments in trial to a jury, apply equally to civil practitioners. However, the law applies to conduct inside and outside the courtroom. PC 745 is generally directed at criminal convictions and sentencing in which either explicit or implicit evidence of racial or other bias played a part. If a violation by an attorney, a judge, an expert witness, a law enforcement officer, or even a juror is found, the result could be a new trial or sentencing hearing for the defendant. It applies equally to intentional and unintentional bias, and seems to retroactively apply to statements and conduct.
The case of People v. Bankston (2026) 19 Cal.5th 786 is illustrative, and specifically disapproves the prior holding in People v. Stubblefield (2024) 107 Cal.App.5th 896. Bankston was a death penalty case, and the Court reversed the death penalty and remanded the penalty finding to the trial court for retrial. The language that the Court found violated the RJA was contained in the prosecutor’s closing argument, in which he referred to the defendant as a “thug” and included a story about how Bengal tigers in the jungle behave differently in a zoo than they do in the jungle. The prosecutor went on to embellish the story by describing the tiger as enormous, having its muscles all flexed out, having its claws and fangs visible, as growling, all in the context of relating these qualities to the defendant’s gang affiliations. The RJA specifically prohibits the use of animal imagery that is objectively understood as appealing to racial bias. The Court went on to prohibit this “Bengal tiger story” from ever being told again in California courtrooms, whatever the actual intent behind the analogy may be.
The legislature is currently considering a similar anti-bias statute to specifically apply to statements and conduct in civil cases. It would be bad enough to see one’s hard work in a case be for naught, but an attorney’s conduct found to be in violation to the anti-bias laws could also lead to professional discipline, even if such language and conduct was engaged in without any malevolent intention.

